(from Living Orthodoxy, #115, later edited for relevance)
When
we think of "mission", most often we think of those who are already
well grounded in the Faith going off into some situation where there
are large numbers of "heathen" whom one hopes will be converted. To a
great extent, in our modern pluralist society, we have become rather
uncomfortable with the concept. Far too often, one hears such
sentiments as "if God means for them to be converted, He will lead them
to the Church."
Such thinking is in glaring contradiction to the
Gospel, which instructs us in no uncertain terms: "Go ye therefore, and
teach all nations, baptizing them in the name of the Father, and of the
Son, and of the Holy Spirit, teaching them to observe all things
whatsoever I have commanded you" (Matt 28:20). Our responsibility for
such mission directs us not only to the unfaithful neighbor next door
(whom we must never forget), but with equal insistence to "all nations".
Sometimes,
however, the mission goes in more than one direction. Sometimes it is
those afar who call out for help, that they may be converted. Such, of
course, was the background of the conversion of Russia. And, indeed,
something very similar has occurred in the formation of the Haitian
Orthodox Mission.
To be sure, in Haiti as in many other
places, most of the population is already "Christian" — the Roman
Catholicism of the French slaveholders remained even after the
colonialists had been expelled, and a century of domination by the
United States has brought its legacy of hundreds of Protestant
denominational missions. There has also been, for quite some time, a
presence of modernist Orthodoxy — the kind of "Orthodoxy" which
interchanges itself without much difficulty with certain forms of
Protestantism.
But the Lord, in His wisdom, prepared ground
for His Word in this all but forgotten country. Certainly, no "mission"
had ever been sent to Haiti from any of our established parishes in
North or South America. Indeed, this would have been a serious
challenge: the people of Haiti speak their own native Creole; those who
have been to school speak French; very few speak any other language.
Such a challenge, however, didn't stop St. Innocent from not only
speaking with but even writing for the Aleut peoples in their own
languages.
Rather than Orthodox missionaries going to Haiti, it
was a handful of native Haitians, seeking the true apostolic Faith, who
sought out the Russian Orthodox Church Outside Russia... in an era when
communications between Haiti and the United States were all but
impossible. A single hieromonk (since gone into apostasy) and his flock
were accepted into the Church in 1994. In the following year Fr.
Jean-Chénier Dumais spent several months at Holy Trinity Monastery
preparing for his ordination to the holy priesthood, and in January
1996 Archbishop Hilarion spent several days visiting the fledgling
mission (a missionary trip reported by Orthodox Life, vol. 46 #1,
Jan-Feb 1996). Regrettably, a period of lack of communication and
confusion followed, which created a great deal of uncertainty amongst
the faithful in the United States... an uncertainty exacerbated by a
slander campaign conducted by a modernist priest.
Fortunately,
good contact was re-established with the surviving priest in Haiti, Fr.
Jean, who in 1998 was able twice to travel to the United States for
Southern Deanery clergy conferences. Those of us who were privileged to
come to know him (even many who could communicate only through an
interpreter) were impressed by his fervor and his sincerity. But we had
only a shadowy idea of the reality.
In the interest of laying to
rest the demons of rumor, and securing a much more concrete
understanding of the conditions in Haiti and, more especially, our
Church's mission there. His Grace, Bishop Gabriel, asked me last fall
to begin making plans for an extended visit.
As I began
preparation in earnest in January, I was at once struck by the
difficulty of obtaining useful information concerning Haiti. I was not
surprised to find that there is no tourist guidebook— but I was
surprised to find that the country is not even mentioned in most
Caribbean guidebooks. I was (misinformed) upon inquiry, that there was
no such information available for Haiti — in fact, there is a quite
extensive and excellent section on Haiti in the Footprint guide to the
Caribbean. I searched for useful reading material... and found one book
only, quite appropriately titled Best Nightmare on Earth: A Life in
Haiti (Herbert Gold, Touchstone, New York 1991, ISBN 0-671-75516-1). I
talked with the two people whom I knew to have visited the country
(Archbishop Hilarion and a local Protestant lay missionary), and
prepared as best I was able (not least, by intense reading in French!).
I
knew, from previous attempts to communicate with Fr. Jean in
Port-au-Prince, that it was entirely possible I would arrive
unexpected: we had no telephone communication, and postal service is
completely unpredictable. I had no idea where or under what conditions
I would be living, except for the certainty that I would not be staying
in one of the few $100+ a night hotels for international
wheeler-dealers. So, with Vladyka's blessing, I boarded a plane early
in February, burdened with the maximum allowable load (and then a bit):
full scale camping gear for myself for tropical conditions, and a hefty
load of donated goods for the mission — vestments, candles, incense,
icons, wine, and an altar Gospel and Apostolos (in French, of course),
as well as some personal items.
After a very enjoyable overnight
stop with Fr. Daniel McKenzie and his family in Miami (which added
somewhat to the volume of material traveling with me!), I arrived at
the Port-au-Prince airport, and felt as if I had traveled back in time
as much as across the water. The "Warning: Inadequate Security" signs I
had seen in Nashville and Miami made sense. Where else can you walk
down the mobile stairway from a giant jetliner to cross the open
tarmac, all directly under the eyes of a huge crowd of watchers on the
observation deck above? I hadn't seen one of those in years. The trip
through customs held a pleasant surprise: the officer wasn't the least
bit interested in what might be in those three heavy bags, but just
waved me through with a friendly smile and a few words of welcome... in
French. In fact, only twice in my two weeks in Haiti did anyone begin
speaking to me in English.
The language of the streets (still
unintelligible to me) is Créole, common to the former French colonies
of the Caribbean. Derived from French, it includes a healthy seasoning
of words from numerous African languages, as well as noticeable amounts
of Spanish and English. It is not, however, merely a degenerate French,
but has a clearly defined spoken and written grammar and vocabulary of
its own, which has been relatively stable for decades. However, even in
the more remote regions of the country almost everyone, it seems,
understands a bit when spoken to in French... but only a rather small
portion of the people (15% is the figure commonly given, probably a
gross overestimate) are able to speak French freely. A much smaller
percentage read and write any language at a meaningful level (opinions
concerning the literacy level vary dramatically, perhaps as a result of
differing definitions of "literacy").
My careful inspection of
the observation balcony while I waited on the tarmac to enter the
customs shed (the word is apt... everywhere signs apologize for its
sorry state, but there is no evidence that any work is being done to
make it any better) led me to the conclusion that my letter to Fr. Jean
had not reached him. Once through customs I was certain it hadn't. I
was on my own.
Risking triteness, I can only describe what I
found outside the barriers as a "swirling mass of humanity." I had no
difficulty finding someone to help with my bags: at least a dozen
people tried. One hefty fellow who spoke reasonable French won the
argument. I had two immediate problems: to find some (safe!) way to
leave the bags in one place while I figured out what to do next, and to
procure some sort of map (my best efforts before departure had
failed... not even the Haitian Consulate in New York could provide me
with one) to aid navigation. I found no reasonable answer to either (I
later learned that in Haiti you get a map from a car-rental agency),
and so ultimately gambled on my hefty taxi-driver, loaded everything
into his truck (many taxis in Haiti are trucks) and set out to find the
Church of the Nativity of Our Lady, where I thought (wrongly) Fr. Jean
& his family lived. (They had lived there the last time I had
spoken with him, but no more.)
My limited information was
sufficient to keep the taxi driver from taking me to another city
altogether (he tried... it turns out there is a "Village Nerette" in
Pétionville, but he knew nothing of the region by the same name within
a half-mile of the airport). Within minutes of leaving the airport
gates, dodging other wildly careening taxis, pedestrians, and a cow or
two, we started up one of the worst roads I have ever traveled... and I
live in the Tennessee mountains. The driver seemed determined to reach
the end of the road (high up the hillside... Port-au-Prince is built on
the slopes of a steep mountainous region which reaches down to the Gulf
of Gonave with scarcely a pause except for the narrow coastal plain at
the bottom) without seeking any kind of directions. Fortunately, Fr.
Jean had told me that the church was very close to the airport... and
had erected a sign on this “main road” pointing to the church school.
The driver, however, was convinced that the church had to be high up on
the mountain, and it took no small argument to convince him to stop.
When he turned around, we were already far enough above the church for
me to see the bright red Orthodox cross on its roof... and he began the
tortuous navigation through areas which might equally well have been
road, yard, playground or pasture — and served as all three — to bring
us to its gate.
Upon later reflection, it became apparent why he
was so hard to convince. The church is located in a "badly organized"
area, a "terrain vague" — squatter land. The land lies low, is poorly
drained, and has no public services. It was undoubtedly considered to
have no value... until people began (for lack of anyplace better) to
build on it. Suddenly it became valuable, and its owner expects to be
paid well for the ground on which the houses (and the church) have been
built. From the outside, no one would consider it a place in which to
find either a church or a school (and to the best of my knowledge there
is no other). It is a good place for both to be.
When we arrived
at the church, school classes were in session, but I quickly learned
that Fr. Jean no longer lived there. One of the teachers dismissed his
class and piled into the taxi as our guide to take us to his home.
Since he and the driver conversed in Créole, it was only when we were
halfway across the city that I came to understand that he was Julbert,
Fr. Jean's younger brother, who lived with him. The trip across the
city was a good introduction to Port-au-Prince and its traffic... and
quickly convinced me that I had no desire (even as a retired Chicago
cabby) to drive in the city. Most vehicles resemble survivors of a
demolition derby; if the other drivers don’t destroy a car, the
conditions of the road certainly will.
The street on which Fr.
Jean and his family live (temporarily) is so steep that the taxi driver
was forced to let the truck down it a few feet at a time, coming to a
complete stop each time. Needless to say, he expected to be richly
rewarded for his labors, and demanded $50 US for the trip. One of my
advance sources had said $20 was standard for a trip from the airport
to the city... but he claimed this was really two trips (first to the
church, all half-mile of it, then to the house). We finally settled for
$32 (all the cash I had in my pocket) and a disgusted look. Do cabbies
ever change?
One by one, I met the members of Fr. Jean's
(extended) family: Julbert, his half-brother, in his twenties; Martin,
his 10-year-old son; Dora, his 4-year- old daughter; 15-year old Mona
and 10-year-old Iphonise, distantly related girls with nowhere else to
live, who have been taken into the family; and Matushka Marie-Chantal.
Each (remember, my coming was unannounced, although Fr. Jean and I had
discussed a possible and hoped-for visit when he was in the US) was
duly astonished and, it seemed, delighted. Fr. Jean himself was the
last of all to return home in the evening. This family of seven live in
a pleasant enough 4-room apartment — but it is theirs only until May or
June, having been leased by a family who plan to go at that time to
Haiti to assist for a year with the school. Previously, they had indeed
been living at the church... in a 12x12' room now used as a classroom
for the school. The combined income of Fr. Jean & Matushka from
three teaching jobs would be insufficient to rent the apartment in
which they are living, even if that were the only expense to be met.
The
apartment is considered a good buy at $4000 per year. It is so
inexpensive (!!) because it is in a portion of the city which, although
it has plumbing in place, does not having any running water, and the
apartment does not have any reservoir water distribution system. All
water must be purchased by the bucketful from a water tanker and
carried, four gallons at a time, up the hill — about 200 yards, my best
guess, and very steep. Such conditions lead one to be very conservative
in water usage. Despite the cost and labor involved, I was offered
water for bathing every morning and evening... and everyone was
surprised that I never wanted the water heated (try and find some cold
water in Haiti!).
I was surprised (in view of Archbishop
Hilarion's warning to be certain to take a flashlight & plenty of
batteries) to discover working electricity at the time of my arrival:
Julbert immediately put the video of the glorification services for St.
John of San Francisco on the VCR (a gift from relatives in New York
City), and watched it avidly for quite some time... until the power
went off in the early evening, remaining off all night. In general, it
seemed, in that sector of the city there was electricity for 5-6 hours
each day, but only once or twice during my stay did this include any of
the evening hours. It came and went without warning or apparent rhyme
or reason. According to a newspaper article I came across, current
generating facilities can provide only somewhat less than a third of
the power demand for Port-au-Prince. It seems that some of the smaller
cities in the country may be somewhat better off in this respect, but
to all intents and purposes there is no electrical power outside the
cities.
It is possible in Port-au-Prince, as in most major
cities of the world, to pass in and out without ever touching or being
touched by the real world outside. There are a few good hotels,
catering to international businessmen, United Nations officials and
high class missionaries, which maintain their own water supplies,
electrical generators, swimming pools... and well-armed security
guards. A traveler might pass from the airport to one of these by taxi,
and back out, with only a glimpse of the seething and suffering city
and country. For me, the first trip across the city, from airport to
church to Fr. Jean's home, was too much, too quickly. I had only just
begun to register the reality around me. I had seen the stick-buildings
along the sides of the road (typically a few slender poles stuck in the
ground with a tarp stretched across the top) — but had not yet realized
that these were combination shop & home for whole families, perhaps
six or eight people cooking, eating, sleeping and selling whatever they
could get their hands on in a hundred square feet or so. The less
fortunate had no tarps or poles. I had seen the piles of trash
everywhere, but not yet realized that there was a reason they were not
mountains (I saw one garbage truck at work in two weeks): if something
thrown on the street could be eaten by anything, something would eat
it; if it could be burned, somebody would burn it for fuel; if neither
of these was possible, sooner or later somebody would use it for
something, incorporating it into a fence if nothing else. Precious
little stayed indefinitely... and that, it appears, works its way
(sometimes with a little human help) slowly down the steep hillside
streets toward the Gulf during the torrential rainstorms.
The
first night, standing on the porch of Fr. Jean's apartment (value
greatly enhanced by its "free air" position... one could look out over
the rooftops of the city below to the Gulf), I could have fooled
myself. I could have forgotten my first, limited vision of the city
(limited not only by my own inability really to see, but also by the
amount of energy required to keep my place in the jolting taxi and pray
that no other driver tried to occupy the same space as we at the same
moment) and thought myself in a very pleasant vacation spot (provided I
didn't mind too much having neither electricity nor running water... a
minor inconvenience, at least for me... as long as I didn't have to
haul the water). I "knew" better, but the reality had not yet entered
into me.
The real jolt came the next day, as I began (in company
with Fr. Jean) to move around the city like "real people", deprived of
the relative insulation of a "private taxi" or the safe haven of a
friend's home. We began with a quick trip to the School of the Nativity
of Our Lady, in session. Currently, the school must use various parts
of the church for classes... one of them in the nave, another tucked
into a tiny room (previously home for Fr. Jean's family) at the west
end of the nave, the third into a storage area behind the altar. There
were about 30 students that morning (there is an afternoon session for
older students, of similar size), most of them residents of the area in
which the church is located.
"Quick trip" refers only to the
time we spent at the school. Getting there was another story. Travel in
Port-au-Prince (unless one has lots of money) is accomplished partly on
foot, partly in "camionettes" — typically, a Toyota pickup truck fitted
with a topper and two benches in the back. Some have two additional
seats welded on over the rear bumper... others have spikes on the
bumper to discourage hangers-on. Alternatively, the vehicle is a badly
banged-up van, usually with the side doors removed altogether. The
camionettes (privately owned) operate over more or less fixed routes,
but there is no source other than street lore for determining where
they start, where they end, or by what route they pass. Normally, they
leave their starting point only when crammed to capacity... or beyond.
I once counted 18 of us in the Toyota variety, another time 24 in a van
(and these are ordinary vans, not the giant variety). People get in and
out every block or two, unavoidably trampling and squeezing one another
in the process. Haiti is no place for anyone troubled by body contact!
Travel by camionette is neither fast nor efficient (sometimes walking
is faster, so bad is the traffic), but it is one of the very few
"bargains" to be found in Haiti. The standard fare is 2 gourdes for a
route (about 12 cents) regardless of the length of the trip; typically,
a cross-town trip will require two or three different vehicles.
Needless
to say, travel by camionette requires a great deal of walking as well,
through streets crowded with vehicles, vendors, animals and refuse.
Only rarely is it possible to walk on a sidewalk... most often, the way
is obstructed by a vendor's stall (which may well be his home as well),
a pile of refuse, or simply too many people to force a way through.
More frequently, one walks in the street, constantly alert to vehicles
coming from either direction. Nominally, one drives on the right, but
this is more something to write in a rule book than a description of
reality. In fact, drivers pass by whatever route is least obstructed
and least likely to damage the vehicle. Pedestrians are not considered
to be dangerous obstacles... and are expected to fend for themselves.
The old tongue- in-cheek aphorism is applicable: "Land of the quick and
the dead: if you aren't quick you'll be dead."
The starting
point of this journey to the church and school was in a well-developed
area of the city... paved streets (albeit badly broken up), water lines
(never mind that they were devoid of water), sewage systems (the only
thing which, amazingly, worked more or less as intended), sidewalks
(even if impassable). The church and school, however, are located in
quite a different kind of region. Even though it is within a mile of
the airport, the area is chaotic and undeveloped... until now. It is a
low- lying, poorly drained area, previously regarded as useless land...
until the intense population pressure of the city and incredibly high
land prices forced poorer people into the area — people who, however,
at least had the "leisure" and the "spare" money to begin to stack
concrete blocks to make a permanent home. In this area, apart from the
one through road, there is no clear distinction between roads,
foot-passages, "yards" and (as yet) unused ground. There is no water
system, no sewage system, no (official or legal) electrical or
telephone system. Many of the homes do not have roofs... the builders
have not yet been able to afford enough blocks and time to reach roof
height; in the meantime, a piece of tarp stretched in a corner serves
as shelter from sun and rain. Random bits of wire stretched from corner
to corner distribute (dangerously and badly) low-power electricity
(enough for a couple of light bulbs, maybe a small fan) to some of the
homes, taken from illegal taps into the power distribution lines at the
edge of the area. Ironically, it is only these illegal electrical lines
which function most of the time... there are no switches for turning
them off.
It is indeed squatter territory... but the land-owner
is now demanding payment for the previously valueless land. Only in
Haiti would it be conceivable to build a church first, then worry about
buying the land on which it stands (unless one considers what a
mortgage really means!)... but that is the situation. It is indeed
quite a building, the fruit of the donations of the faithful over the
past 2-3 years and the tireless labor of Fr. Jean in designing and
masterminding its construction. When I first saw photographs of our
"church building" in Port-au-Prince, it was of an open pole structure
with a palm- and banana-leaf roof. Later, I saw photos of concrete
block walls, with the same kind of roof. I was rather surprised when I
actually reached the church to find that it was a finished building
(Haitian style). The roof of the first floor is designed to be the
floor of the second (as in nearly all Haitian buildings under
construction): it is composed of concrete blocks, cement and
reinforcing steel laid over a temporary scaffold. Although it is quite
invulnerable to hurricanes or fire, the thought of an earthquake (rare
enough in Haiti that no one thinks about them) is frightening. Rebar
protrudes from its roof, as it does from nearly all buildings which
have reached that point, against the day when another story can be
added. At first glance, the raw concrete block is very unsightly, and
it was quite some time before I realized that this is only the first
stage. To finish the building (very few in the area of the church are
so finished) requires plaster-work inside and out, perhaps with the
addition of some mosaic tile Once this is accomplished, these buildings
can be quite attractive.
Building a home (or church) in such
territory demands a lot of digging, and all over the region there are
holes in various stages. Some of them are destined to become
underground cisterns for water storage (the church has two — one for
rainwater collected from the roof, a second for water purchased from a
water-tanker), others to become septic holding tanks, which must be
pumped out when full (the church has one, with a two-seater outhouse).
All
these holes are dug by hand (fortunately, the soil is not terribly hard
to dig) — in my two weeks in Haiti I never saw a backhoe or other power
digging tool.
The church building is quite large, capable of
holding perhaps 200 people (standing!). The altar is spacious. Two
small rooms at the back are destined ultimately to serve, one as the
baptistry, the other as a candle-stand (and book/gift shop?!). At
present, they must be used as a classroom and the office for the
school. The church is adorned with a number of icons, gifts from
faithful around the world — but larger icons are needed in many places.
The unusual number of chairs and benches is steadily dwindling — a
remnant of the past history of the mission (once attached to a
modernist Orthodox jurisdiction), many still needed for the
schoolchildren who must use the nave as a classroom).
Such was
my introduction to the church building and school-children... brief,
hot, and astonishingly dusty. February is "winter" — which means that
temperatures rarely climb above 90, one stops sweating most nights, and
rain is scarce. Later in my visit I was to experience one of those rare
rains... and its effect on the powdery soil, entirely nude of pavement
of any kind, in the area of the church. It makes me shudder to think of
the result when it really rains.
After walking back to the
airport, we began our journey (again by camionette) to the center-city,
to visit the Roman Catholic school at which both Fr. Jean and Matushka
teach (at least until the end of this term — we sincerely hope to raise
enough pledges for a living salary for the family, so that they may be
free to devote their energies to our own school and to the parish).
Part-way there, traffic was completely stalled, so we took to the
pavement, making the last couple of miles on foot. "Crowded" took on a
new meaning for me. For most of the distance, I doubt that I was ever
more than a few inches from the nearest person, and I never passed more
than a few seconds without direct physical contact with someone. For
me, this was not troubling — but it was exhausting, and I was relieved
to move into the less-crowded streets near the school. As we walked, I
became accustomed not only to close-up friendly greetings... but also,
a bit farther off, to shouts of "Papa Nicholas!"— an alternative
greeting/observation to "blanc—white!"
In fact, white people are
so rare in Port-au-Prince that after leaving the airport upon my
arrival I didn't see another white face until we visited the
(charmingly quaint) Oloffson Hotel for dinner on Friday evening;
neither did I hear another word of English until that time. The shouts
on the street seem to be neither particularly friendly, nor are they
hostile — rather, an exclamatory reaction to an unusual event. There
are, of course, many whites in Haiti... but they are largely confined
to the immediate area of foreign diplomatic or religious missions, or
UN centers.
Entering into the yard of the Roman Catholic school
where Fr. Jean & Matushka teach, I was immediately surrounded by a
small knot of little fellows (6-10 year olds, I would say) eager to
hold my hand. It was only a matter of moments before somebody shouted
"Papa Nicholas", and before long I was surrounded by two or three
dozen... and found myself being controlled by the crowd, rather than
the other way around. I was certainly in no jeopardy, as there were
several teachers close by (Fr. Jean was inside the building on some
errand), but I became increasingly uncomfortable with the situation
(amongst other things, there were a few anonymous hands probing the
pockets of my cassock. .. I was pleased that they were very deep!). I
worked myself back against a wall and began to tell the boys that the
game had gone far enough, and they should let me be... but against the
din of the "Papa Nicholas!" chorus I wasn't heard too well. One of the
teachers got the message, and approached, stick in hand. The results
were immediate, but only momentary. In the end, he and another teacher
hustled me across the courtyard and out a large iron gate, which was
opened only wide enough to permit one person through. It was a rather
disconcerting experience, as I realized (once again... I had
experienced something similar in a street demonstration during my
radical political days a few lifetimes ago) how quickly a benign crowd
can become a threatening mob... even when it is made up of children.
Perhaps the perception is especially appropriate at the moment I write,
just a week away from Palm Sunday.
As the day, and the days
following, wore on, I became acutely aware of the extraordinary
expenditure of energy needed for the accomplishment of the slightest
task, and the astonishing patience required for survival. From the eyes
of a north American, some of this seems entirely needless, and the
impulse to get in there and "fix it" is strong. Yet, from within the
reality of Haiti, it begins to take on a sense of inevitability.
There
are very few working "stores" in Port-au-Prince... most of the commerce
is on the streets. At first, this is a bit puzzling. Every block
consists primarily of closed-up buildings, with the side-walks in front
crowded with vendors. The occasional open store, with rare exceptions,
has a locked door tended by an armed guard... not infrequently with the
police equivalent of a sawed-off shotgun prominently displayed. After
some days, it suddenly dawned on me that, under the urban conditions of
Port-au-Prince, stores as we know them could only be operated if they
had their own power supplies and their own security; otherwise, most of
the time they would be blacked-out holes in the wall. My forays into
such stores (mostly bookstores) were an instruction in themselves.
First, in order to find anything, it was necessary to call upon the
services of one of the shopkeepers. Once ready to purchase, it was
necessary to go to another to have the sale written up. A third was
required in order to pay for the sale (in one instance this required an
extended visit while yet another went to another store where the phone
was working to call in for authorization on the charge card). Finally,
the shopper has to pass muster with the security guard in order to
exit. Result? — a simple purchase can require an hour or more, without
accounting for the considerable time required to reach the store in the
first place.
Tasks which we would expect to require "just a
minute" can stretch on for a large part of a day. More than once in the
two weeks I spent in Haiti a half-day or so was spent in what proved to
be totally useless (except for the experience of traveling through the
city, valuable in itself for me) coming and going, attempting to
accomplish some task which could not be completed... time which could
have been "saved" had there been a reliably working telephone system or
other means of communication. Currently, there is no telephone at the
church (and can't be), none at Fr. Jean's home (though there is one a
couple of houses away which he can use when it works), and none at Fr.
Deacon Gregory's home. Consequently, no kind of planning or
decision-making can be accomplished without risking several hours of
travel in the hope that one will find the person or supplies needed.
I
got several samples of this, but in some ways the most instructive
occurred on Saturday. We left Fr. Jean's home shortly after noon, with
two objectives to be accomplished before going to the church for
Vespers. Fortunately, both were in the same place. The first was to
inspect a house which is being offered for a three-year lease, which
would make an excellent rectory and guesthouse... not least because it
is across the street from Deacon Gregory's home. The second purpose was
to visit Fr. Gregory, if possible... he did not yet even know I was in
the country. The visit to the house, which belongs to a doctor who is
coming to the United States for further training, was pre-arranged...
she does have a telephone, and Fr. Jean had arranged the appointment
the previous day from the school where he teaches. The visit to Fr.
Gregory was not, and in the event, neither he nor Matushka were at
home. Had our sole purpose been to visit them, the entire trip would
have been in vain.
The trip from Fr. Jean's home to the house
and thence to the church took the entire afternoon — over four hours of
travel in all. I arrived at the church already thoroughly exhausted,
and realized that it had taken far more energy just to get to church
than we, under more "normal" circumstances, are accustomed to investing
in an entire Vigil. The service was my first introduction to the
congregation of Fr. Jean's parish... and I was rather surprised to find
that the little folk I had met a couple of days earlier at the school
predominated.
Unlike many of the other parishioners, they live
within a short distance of the church, and so could walk to Vespers.
Unfortunately, under present conditions a Vigil is not ordinarily
possible: the area is not secure, remaining after dark is ill advised,
and the intense heat makes it almost unthinkable to begin a long
service at its worst in mid-afternoon (and I was there in the middle of
winter!). We scurried out of the area as twilight fell, returning home
long after dark (to the accompaniment of roving pre-Carnival bands of
singer/dancers).
Sunday Liturgy (the first of two I had the
privilege to serve with Fr. Jean during my stay) was a spiritually and
emotionally overwhelming experience. Filled with sad awareness of the
incredible difficulty and poverty of the people around me, and
painfully aware of the relative ease and luxury in which even the
poorest of our own poor lived, the words of the Beatitudes struck me
afresh, as if heard for the first time. Indeed, the forced
concentration required for serving in a language which I understood
perfectly well but nevertheless was far from "second nature" for me,
many of the words of the Liturgy came to me that way. By God's
providence, the two Sundays I served with these "least of our brethren"
to the south were the Sunday of the Prodigal Son, and the Sunday of the
Last Judgment. Needless to say, the words of the Gospel in both cases
penetrated more deeply than ever.
The power of the Holy Spirit
indeed overshadowed us in that Liturgy, so much so that I reached the
end of giving Holy Communion (Fr. Jean had insisted that I serve as
principal celebrant) only with great difficulty. There were perhaps 60
or 65 present for Divine Liturgy each Sunday, of whom certainly more
than half received the Holy Mysteries. Each Sunday, Fr. Jean preached
after the Gospel, predominantly in Creole, evidently with much power,
judging from the people's intent concentration. Each time, he insisted
that I preach again at the end of the Liturgy (in French, of course)...
an experience which I faced the first time with much trepidation. I
need not have feared — the words were indeed given, inadequate as I was
to the task, and were warmly received (to my astonishment, with a round
of applause the first Sunday... not a custom we would care to
encourage, I think!).
Most evenings during my visit some time
was spent discussing liturgical and pastoral questions. Often these
arose in the course of casual conversation as we traveled around the
city... but my command of the language was not adequate to carrying on
serious discussion over the hubbub of the traffic and crowds. Often I
was asked to spend some time helping members of the family with English
studies, which must be encouraged. Although "linguistic imperialism" is
not the least desirable, there is little realistic hope for much
contact between these, our brethren in the Faith, and their only near
neighbors (the faithful of the United States) without some language
studies on both sides. Unfortunately, I have more hope that some of our
Haitian brethren will learn English tolerably well, than that very many
of the faithful here will invest the necessary energy to learn French
or Creole. I would be delighted to be proven wrong!
After my
return home, I spoke with one of my brother priests about my
disappointment in realizing how inadequate were my words and the
photographs with which I returned, for my desire somehow to convey to
the faithful here what I had encountered. His response was very much to
the point — no, just words and pictures won't do it; you would have to
be able to bring back the sound and the smell and the physical contact,
all of it. Of course, that really can't be done. The wholeness of that
reality was so overwhelming that after only a few days I had been
"filled up" to the bursting point. The mere words "culture shock" took
on a very concrete meaning for me, and I knew that I had been wise from
the outset in planning for an "interlude" of a few days during the
second week of my visit to spend some time alone (at least, away from
the city) either in the mountains or at the seashore. The latter proved
to be the more practical. Accordingly, I hired a driver and vehicle (an
out of service camionette... a 10-year old Toyota pickup with about
110,000 miles on it which its owner would very much like to sell for
the bargain price of $10,000 US) for an excursion beyond the city, with
the objective of finding and settling in a seaside hotel somewhere for
three or four days. In principle, this should have been fairly
simple... I even had the name and location of a highly recommended
hotel at a distance of about 30 miles from the city.
But nothing
is simple in Haiti. For starters, the truck was parked in the courtyard
of the building in which Fr. Jean and his family live... blocked into
place by two other vehicles which belong to the owner of the building.
He had urgent errands, but promised to return "shortly" to move them.
Our planned 7AM start was delayed for quite some time as we first
waited for him to return, then got tired of waiting and decided that if
enough muscle were applied we could reposition a pile of sand and the
two other trucks (by sliding them sideways) sufficiently to extricate
our own. It worked... but took well over an hour. Another two hours
passed before we emerged from the west side of Port-au-Prince into the
long string of small towns which line the west-bound "highway". This
road deteriorated rapidly as we worked our way through towns, potholes,
live- stock and crowds of people toward the town we thought to be our
objective. After several false leads, we finally obtained what seemed
to be definitive information: the hotel in question was no more, and no
one knew of any possible place such as that for which I was looking on
that part of the coast.
So we pushed on to the west, as far as
Mirogoane, about 60 miles west of Port-au-Prince. It felt like at least
200, given the travel conditions. I had never felt threatened in
Port-au-Prince, but Mirogoane made me distinctly uneasy. Only recently,
long after my return, did I discover that it is renowned as a smuggling
center.
Beyond Mirogoane, the road is said to deteriorate
rapidly, so much so that most "bus" service has been discontinued. My
driver, Sergiou, was reluctant to continue, so we determined to return
almost to Port-au-Prince and cross the mountains to Jacmel, on the
south coast, where he said there were several nice hotels... a
possibility also hinted at by the little information I had been able to
glean from a business traveler's guide I had seen, and the Haiti
information site on the Web. To my astonishment, the road over the
mountains was an excellently built highway. I was never able to
determine exactly how it came about, but it was apparently built by a
French consortium three years ago. The trip was a bit hair-raising (no
self-respecting Haitian driver, even the very best, would consider
taking a blind curve any other way than in the middle of the road with
the horn blaring), but by contrast quite rapid and smooth. The drop
into the tropical lushness of Jacmel was in stark contrast to the
barren mountainsides through which we had been traveling.
After
a couple of false starts, with the help of another (paid) guide, I
found myself in what seemed another Haiti. I speak of it here only
because I think it is important for us to realize the extent to which
beauty and squalidness, material poverty and spiritual richness,
economic desperation and personal hopefulness are intermingled in
Haiti. Although beyond the means of all but the most affluent Haitians,
the seaside villa hotel to which we were guided was nevertheless an
outpost of hope. It provided me with the emotional refuge I needed...
and obviously served the same purpose for many others. As a beautiful
vacation spot I would not hesitate to recommend it to anyone who could
tolerate the extraordinary effort required to reach it. In fact,
however, so far as I know there were no "ordinary vacationers" there.
There were staff members from the United Nations mission in Jacmel who
lived there full-time, doctors from Peoria, Illinois, who were staffing
a part-time clinic a few houses down the coast, a few Haitians, a
pleasant English couple who had come to visit their daughter who is
engaged in UN human rights observation in the central highlands... and
me. With them, I spoke English, for the first time since arriving in
Haiti (the hotel staff speak little or no English, however). Although
they declared themselves to be atheists, they took a lively interest in
my presence and work and hopes, and continue (by email) to maintain
contact and interest and support for the Mission.
Almost every
source of information concerning Haiti (including Fr. Jean) insists
upon the lively religious interest of the people. I had no reason to
question this... but at Jacmel I got a stunning demonstration.
Repeatedly, as Fr. Jean & I traveled around the city, he was
questioned by fellow "waiters" (for a camionette) or passengers, but I
had had little part in these discussions, as they were almost always
entirely in Creole. (Even those Haitians who are perfectly fluent in
French slide quickly into Creole if they get a bit excited.) But at
Jacmel I was alone... or so I thought. One day, taking a break from
normal routine (which included a lot of work on the English Octoechos,
of which publication is currently underway), I started out for a walk
along a shoreside path running eastward from the hotel, about which
George and Jean, my English friends, had told me. I had not gone 50
yards before I had one companion (a boy of about l0), and within a
quarter-mile I had three. Soon the questions began to pour out, and
within a half-mile I had to give up the idea of walking (the going was
pretty rough) and concentrate on answering the boys (who also wanted
instruction in English, mixed in with everything else). Within minutes,
the conversation turned to religion (at their initiative), and I found
myself faced with the daunting task of explaining to these youngsters
(the other two were sixteen and eighteen) why and how the Orthodox
Church was neither Roman Catholic nor Protestant, and how all this had
come about... in French. No sooner had I "finished" than we were joined
by a third young man, Ernstceau, who was sixteen... who insisted on
hearing it all over again.
He came back the next day for more, joining me on another expedition (out onto the headlands to take a photograph of the hotel and cove
from the sea side). Again, the questions were persistent... including a
desire to know how old I was. When I told him I was 58, he thought I
was making a joke. No one is that old, he said, except for a rare
grandfather who can barely get around. I finally did convince him I was
telling the truth. Two days ago, I discovered that the average life
expectancy for a Haitian male today is under 48 years. Those "old"
people I saw here and there were in their forties, maybe fifties;
anyone older is a rare phenomenon.
I returned to Port-au-Prince
at the end of the week with a renewed hope and eagerness. Haiti is a
country which is vibrantly alive despite a crushing poverty beyond our
imagination. Everywhere, there are young people struggling, above all
else, to learn. Ernstceau was no exception... every day he walks 5
miles each way to and from school; the bicycle he once had is broken
beyond repair, and he cannot afford the 12¢ camionette fare each way.
He does it eagerly... and dressed far more neatly than most of the
schoolchildren around us. He uses books which have already seen many
years of use, but his are in better condition than many. I saw children
working with books all but obliterated from years of handling. But
everywhere I saw evidence of the oft-repeated refrain: Haitians are a
proud people.
I saw it in the schools on almost every street
corner... almost all of them operated by churches, as the government
has little to offer. I saw it in the astonishingly neat and clean dress
of these people who have to make their way from home to school or work
over and through piles of refuse. They can't do anything about the
refuse... but they can do something about their clothes. I saw it in
the warm smiles which were everywhere. I saw it in the eagerness to
learn, to help... and the expressed determination to do something to
help their own brothers and sisters.
In such a spirit I
celebrated the Sunday of the Last Judgment with our brothers and
sisters to the south. We shared a festal meal after the Liturgy, at Fr.
Jean's insistence (he didn't ask me, he told me it was going to
happen). I was troubled by the probable expense, for I had long since
realized that nothing is cheap in Haiti. Almost everything costs at
least as much as it would in the United States but the annual per
capita income in Haiti is less than $300. The minimum wage was recently
raised to $2.75/day, which to all intents and purposes put an end to
the sweatshop "transformation industries" (fly in a planeload of parts
from somewhere else, pay slave wages to have them assembled in a
warehouse close to the airport, and fly them back out as finished
gizmos of one or another sort — there is cheaper labor to be had
elsewhere in the Caribbean). So I insisted that I be allowed to pay for
this feast. It was a nice meal, but far from lavish: a piece or two of
chicken or goat, some nicely cooked vegetables, dessert, and a soft
drink. We served about 60 people, at a cost of $150 for the food, $50
for the caterer who prepared it while we were all at Liturgy, and $20
for the truck and driver to bring it to the church.
A very
little quick figuring and brainpower suffice to make one realize why
most Haitians are seriously undernourished. One international source
puts 3/4 of the people below the "absolute minimum" nutritional level
required for reasonable health. Extreme starvation (death from acute
dehydration & dysentery in most cases) is relatively rare, but one
of my doctor friends in Jacmel assured me that a very large proportion
of the population suffers from mild to acute protein starvation.
Can
we do anything about it? For the country as a whole, certainly not...
except to pray fervently, and, whenever we get a chance, to urge a
massive humane response from this "big brother" to the north in place
of the destructive militarism we have visited upon the Haitians in the
past. But on a smaller scale, we most certainly can do something... and
we must, if we dare to look ourselves in the face and call ourselves
Christians.
We can do something significant and important, not
only for our Orthodox brethren in Haiti, but for all those whom they
may touch. We can help to build a Church community which is capable,
not only of living and worshipping in an Orthodox fashion (important as
that is), but of actively proclaiming the Gospel to those around
them... in word and in deed. To do so, the Mission needs help to do
better what has already been begun, even in the midst of terrible
temptations.
The support which has already been given to the
Mission has been well used: there is an alive and active parish, with a
respectable building in which to worship; there is a functioning
school, providing education (at almost no cost... few of the students
are able to pay even the nominal fee the school asks) to children who
otherwise would have no school. There can be much more. The three-grade
school should become, at minimum, a full eight-year primary school,
both for small children and for adolescents and adults. There should be
a clinic. A distribution center for clothing and food assistance is
essential - emergency food for those truly in desperation, and guidance
and a source of supply for improved nutrition for those who can afford
to buy food, but have neither the knowledge nor the sources from which
to acquire adequate food at low cost. The list could go on and on.
If
such a firm foundation is built, there is every reason to hope that in
time the Mission could become largely self-supporting. There is reason
to hope that within the foreseeable future it might have not just one,
but numerous parishes, both in Port-au-Prince and in the countryside.
It can happen, and it might happen even without our financial support.
But we need to give that support just as much as the Mission needs to
receive it.
We need to make it possible for the Mission to
provide vital services to those around the church... this requires
space other than the church building proper. We need to make it
possible for Fr. Jean and his family to have a secure home at least for
the next few years, not fearing that in a month or two or three they
will be forced back into completely inadequate housing or onto the
street. We need to provide for guest facilities, so that interested
visitors might be able to stay within the Church community, and so
share in the life of the real Haiti. We need to provide for the travel
required for Mission personnel and others of the parish, that readers
and catechists and deacons and priests may be trained. All this is
possible.
What is needed in the immediate future would not buy
one "entry-level" house in an American subdivision. We are perfectly
able to raise large amounts of money for the building of our own
churches, for the repair of historic churches in other parts of the
world... and these are good and worthy things to do. But the Lord God
may not look kindly upon us if we do not also give freely to those of
our brethren who are so poor that a single low income subsidy in this
country would "provide" for a dozen families amongst them.
The Lord loves a cheerful giver. May He smile upon each one who reads this and responds appropriately!